All very valid points Mark. I agree that if the rules were being written from scratch with the current technology usage, then no longer permitting 40MHz would most likely feature. I admit that 2.4GHz is certainly much better, barring the reported bind problems and other small issues that Gary mentioned.
Aside from this new rule resulting in a lot of 40MHz sets getting 'chucked' (unless we all took up RC boats - I'm only interested in that if I can fit my drum on it :twisted: ) I reckon some of the grief may also have stemmed from the fact that, as you state, the proposal of this rule seems to have missed the consulation period with the membership and the first anyone heard about it (to my knowledge) was when Rob posted it at the beginning of this thread.
That sounds like a sensible and much more reasoned way to approach the situation. If rules can be written, then they should be able to be reviewed and re-written easily enough.when a lot of respected people voice their concerns of an out right ban I think it needs looking into. Maybe what it should say is that all new robots should use 2.4GHz/459MHz systems and if you want to use something else contact the EO first.
To those who have also raised objections to/questioned the need for the new rule (Paul, Grant, Gary etc); what do you think Mark's statement? Would you agree with that or would you still like to see either
a) tests carried out to determine if multiple 2.4GHz usage is the problem, or
b) 40MHz to remain in the rules for people to use freely from 2010?
I personally wouldn't mind so much allowing people currently operating on 40MHz the discretion of staying on 40MHz with encouragement for new builders to plump for 2.4GHz; just curious to see how the rest of us feel?
And Ed, you are correct, I have only really experienced the slightly smaller RC events, having not yet made it to an RL or RR event so I don't have any bigger experiences to draw conclusions from. Out of the 11 events I've attended since starting out, I've never really had any major problems though of the nature described - maybe I just got lucky with a damn good Tx/Rx combo![]()




Reply With Quote
Bookmarks