Please excuse me if this sounds confrontational, its not intended to be.
If the link gets shorted so that theres power to the drive, the first accidental nudge of a transmitter is going to cause trouble.
If the receiver wasnt on a separate battery supply, shorting the link would supply power to it too, surely?
I like the original concept that lights off *should* mean dead. Absolutely dead. Not just ought to be dead.
What makes you think that was the original concept? Maybe it was, maybe it wasnt - whichever way, the rule was written before this argument started. Lights off can also mean lights broken, or a broken wire somewhere - we established a while ago that no-one should take the lack of a light to mean the robot was safe.
Id be amenable to the concept of multiple removable links for different parts of the design, if people must keep the parts independent. So long as the removal of *any* of them kills the robot (assuming the failsafes work).
Multiple links are explicitly allowed in the rules. If you add the requirement that removing any links must stop the robot, you have outlawed clusterbots.
Another thing to think about - if removing the link kills the receiver, then reinserting the link will power up the receiver at the same time as your drive. The high power components will then be starting up with undetermined inputs. Not wise.
All this is irrelevant anyway, the original argument is just about indicator lights. I can comply with any rules that are given (Ill just put gaffer tape over any lights that dont go off) I would just like an official answer.




Reply With Quote
Bookmarks