Possible S900 replacment?

[mattsdragons]

http://www.cornwallmodelboats.co.uk/...og/cem900.html

Voltages are good, RPM isn't stupid but still would need a bit of gearing

Looks possible???

Edit: I should really stop typing so quickly so I don't spell titles wrong -_-

[Ellis]

I have seen these before but am a tad suspicious of it being such low rpm at nominal voltage, and a true stall amperage of 20a is very low. Get the feeling it might be a bit powerless. Hopefully someone has already experimented and they're actually viable...

[mattsdragons]

The torpedo 850 look pretty good but I have got to wonder if these could work, be good to know if anyone has tried them out

[maddox10]

John Lear tried them. Gutless is a good description.

[mattsdragons]

Well, there goes that idea hahaha

What seems to be the next best to the S900?

[maddox10]

There are speed 700 sized motors with powerlevels of the real 900's, common in the RC cars, but those need a 2 stage gearing, what results in complex setups, and a higher cost.
In the end, you're back to frankensteining drill gearboxes and such.

I myself am betting on brushless.

[Flag Captured]

I myself am betting on brushless.

I share that view, given a bit of work brushless seems like it would be all round a better idea than brushed, especially given the state of play with Speed 900s being discontinued and such.
Not to mention the power on paper seems to be much greater for brushless...

[mattsdragons]

No hope for the torpedo 850's?

[maddox10]

Nope and neither for the Graupner speed 720 . Those are paraplegic.

[mattsdragons]

There seems a problem with the esc's though, finding stuff that can switch at the rate we need but god knows what would make a good brushless esc for drive