No point trying to make a walker. Even if you manage to turn up with a walker that survives a spinner, the spinner owners will just ban it.
Printable View
No point trying to make a walker. Even if you manage to turn up with a walker that survives a spinner, the spinner owners will just ban it.
What's that supposed to mean Ceri?
A degree of freedom needs to be independent of another - if you have two degrees of freedom from a leg it should be able to move up and down and forward and back independently, not in a combined motion such that cams produce. Think about the way the leg moves on scuttlebot or other shufflers, it is passing through a fixed trajectory of which only speed and direction are controlled, you need to add more variation than this.
I personally think shufflers ought to get a minimal weight bonus, say 125%, to encourage creativity.
k, my initial thoughts for a design apply, then. That's nice :)
That was basically my idea, I have the designs for it and everything, parts spec'd, costed up but its around 3 thousand with no mess ups. Its also why my machine isn't called Eventorizon. I am saving it for that!Quote:
Originally Posted by typhoon_driver
Besides I cant see any team with a spinner wanting to ban walkers. They might get defeated a few times but they will come back until that one time they can pull the legs off one by one like a spider :-) I would even if I had to loose 10 times to do it. It would be so worth it!
This walkers thing needs to move to a new thread, or resurrect the old one. As for this build, start at the bottom and work up. It may not be what you want but you wont waste a load of money and time like I did.
Not inferring you Gary. You'd fight anything. :DQuote:
Originally Posted by typhoon_driver
Every time someone mentions the walkers weight advantage there's normally a legion of spinner owners making huge arguments on why it shouldn't have the weight advantage for the event they May put it into a spinner. Don't think something actually qualifying for the champs will stop it.
& then there was the Robochallenge proposal to make it easier for spinners at the AGM.
Then the discussion about raising arena walls comes from a spinner owner & gets shot down by flippers.
Then someone else argues about the pit. Or the colour of the LED. Or anything.
Politics. I'm sick of it all to be Frank. I want to turn up, have fun & walk away with something I can fix cheaply & with the contents of my toolkit.
I'm probably not going to comment after this post because I have no experience to draw-upon nor to give my POV any credence, plus I'd like to get this thread back to the friendly advice of people helping me with my first build and somewhat lofty ideas.
But clearly if the weight allowance for walkers were such a huge advantage there would be lots OF them, rather than precisely none whatsoever. Case closed I reckon.
Hiya,
At the end of the day, its up to you what you build, and I personally would love to see some incredible fighting walking machine around today but i would say that getting a box on wheels going is a very good idea, if nothing else it will show you how to set up radio gear, escs batteries for robot use. I would try and basically build anarchy, if you think carefully about weight from the beginning, and use lipos etc you should just about have enough weight to properly amour the thing in 13.6kg.
My thoughts anyway. Cheers.
Yeah, it's advice I am seeing repeated and I'm gonna follow it. Not to build anarchy especially, but to start with a wheeeled box for FW while other things happen. This bot, the eventual walker is still a project though, it's one that will probably take a year or two.
OWCH!!! I've just seen the cost of fast-switching solenoid valves! I may have to design a kind of timed distributor instead :( Christ, walkers earn their weight!